Songs in the Attic (1981)
1. Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway
2. Summer, Highland Falls
3. Streetlife Serenader
4. Los Angelenos
5. She's Got a Way
6. Everybody Loves You Now
7. Say Goodbye to Hollywood
8. Captain Jack
9. You're My Home
10.The Ballad of Billy the Kid
11.I've Loved These Days
With Songs in the Attic, released in 1981, Billy Joel undertook a rare and quietly ambitious project: rather than issue a conventional greatest hits live album, he selected lesser-known material from his earliest records and reintroduced it in concert form. The result is not only a retrospective but a creative correction—an opportunity to revisit songs that had been overlooked due to underwhelming studio production or limited exposure at the time of their original release.
Joel, now an established figure in American popular music, used this moment to draw a clear line between his early songwriting and his later professional polish. In the liner notes, he states explicitly that songs already realized to his satisfaction—such as Piano Man—were intentionally excluded. Instead, he focused on compositions that, in his view, had been underserved by the constraints of youth, inexperience, or subpar recording circumstances.
This approach could have easily faltered, but the execution is remarkably strong. Backed by the touring band that had been central to his recent success, Joel breathes new life into these earlier tracks. Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) and Summer, Highland Falls are elevated in both energy and clarity. The Ballad of Billy the Kid, already ambitious in its studio form, becomes bolder and more defined. Perhaps most impressive is Captain Jack, whose live rendition surpasses the original in intensity and emotional resonance.
The album’s structure—recorded in both large arenas and small clubs—adds a curious, though occasionally jarring, dynamic. The variation in crowd size and acoustic setting can feel disjointed at times, though it also serves to highlight the adaptability of the material. Joel offers justification for this format in the album’s original sleeve notes, but one might argue that a more consistent setting would have provided greater cohesion.
Two singles, Say Goodbye to Hollywood and She’s Got a Way, were reissued from this collection and received a level of acclaim previously denied to their original versions. In fact, many of the tracks here would become more familiar to fans in these live forms than in their studio counterparts. For that reason, Songs in the Attic occupies a unique place in Joel’s catalog: it is both a reappraisal and a reaffirmation.
Rather than exploit his popularity by issuing a live album packed with hits, Joel chose to showcase the depth of his earlier songwriting, confident in its intrinsic merit once properly framed. In doing so, he not only vindicated his past but also invited his growing audience to engage more fully with his artistic history. The decision proved wise, and the execution—sincere, deliberate, and musically sound—ensured its enduring place in his body of work.
Back To Main Page
Go To Next Review