Streetlife Serenade (1974)
1. Streetlife Serander
2. Los Angelenos
3. The Great Suburban Showdown
4. Root Beer Rag
5. Roberta
6. The Entertainer
7. Last of the Big Time Spenders
8. Weekend Song
9. Souvenir
10.The Mexican Connection
Following the moderate success of Piano Man, Billy Joel’s third studio effort, Streetlife Serenade, stands as a transitional work—more notable for what it suggests about Joel’s uneasy relationship with the industry than for the strength of its content. Recorded during a period of geographic and artistic dislocation, the album reveals a performer still searching for his definitive voice, hindered both by circumstances and, in this case, a paucity of truly inspired material.
On paper, the signs were promising. Joel had relocated to Los Angeles, and his previous record had yielded a career-defining title track. Yet Streetlife Serenade bears all the hallmarks of a rushed follow-up: inconsistent tone, underdeveloped lyrics, and a sonic polish that often fails to compensate for the underlying thinness of the songwriting. The production, while marginally more refined than his debut, still lacks the vigor and clarity that would define his later work.
The album begins with its strongest moments. The "title" track, Streetlife Serenader, is elegantly composed, with Joel’s piano weaving through the melody with characteristic dexterity. The Entertainer, a cynical, fast-paced commentary on the music business, displays Joel’s burgeoning wit and rhythmic sharpness—a kindred spirit to Travelin’ Prayer from Piano Man. Here, Joel’s frustration finds form, and the result is engaging, even infectious.
Unfortunately, the rest of the album seldom lives up to these openers. The Great Suburban Showdown attempts social critique but is undermined by pedestrian imagery and lethargic pacing. Los Angelenos and Roberta both suffer from lyrical awkwardness and uninspired arrangements—Joel’s voice, at times strained, is left to carry material that never quite justifies its inclusion.
Instrumentally, Streetlife Serenade is perhaps most interesting, if not entirely successful. Root Beer Rag, a ragtime homage performed at breakneck speed, showcases Joel’s keyboard flair but is marred by synthetic overproduction. The Mexican Connection, a cinematic instrumental closer, aspires to grandeur but lands somewhere between novelty and TV theme pastiche. Souvenir, a quiet, introspective track, hints at a depth that is never fully explored—its brevity feels less like economy and more like a missed opportunity.
This is, in every sense, Joel’s “California album.” His brief tenure on the West Coast—professionally unmoored and creatively adrift—is reflected in the album’s thematic restlessness. The longing for New York, both literal and symbolic, is palpable. Even at his weakest, Joel’s identity is rooted in the grit and melancholy of the East Coast—a sensibility that this album, despite occasional promise, fails to reconcile with its West Coast trappings.
Streetlife Serenade is not without merit, but it is ultimately a document of frustration: of talent misapplied, of songs not yet realized, of an artist in transit. It would take a return to his native ground—and a fresh injection of purpose—for Joel’s full potential to crystallize.
Back To Main Page
Go To Next Review