Live in New York City (2001)


						
Disc One  
  1. My Love Will Not Let You Down
  2. Prove it All Night
  3. Two Hearts
  4. Atlantic City
  5. Mansion on the Hill
  6. The River
  7. Youngstown
  8. Murder Incorporated
  9. Badlands
  10.Out in the Street
  11.Born to Run
  
Disc Two
  1. Tenth Avenue Freeze-Out
  2. Land of Hopes and Dreams
  3. American Skin (41 Shots)
  4. Lost in the Flood
  5. Born in the U.S.A.
  6. Don't Look Back
  7. Jungleland
  8. Ramrod
  9. If I Should Fall Behind

 

The return of the E Street Band at the dawn of the new millennium was nothing short of a cultural event. Having reunited for the Greatest Hits compilation and an ensuing tour—remarkably without the usual studio album to anchor it—Springsteen and company found themselves once again at the center of the rock and roll universe. And where better to immortalize such a moment than Madison Square Garden? The ingredients were certainly in place for a definitive live statement. What resulted, however, was a document curiously inconsistent—at times brilliant, at others bloated.

The album Live in New York City should, by rights, be the ultimate souvenir. It draws deeply from a career that defies standard retrospection, packed with songs that have aged not as relics, but as vital statements of purpose. Springsteen, unlike most legacy artists, has always treated his concerts as living, breathing acts of communion. Setlists shift nightly, hits often go unplayed, and obscurities take center stage with the confidence of gospel. In this sense, Live in New York City succeeds: many tracks appear in live form for the first time, and the selection avoids redundancy with the earlier Live 1975–1985 box set.

Yet the performance occasionally undercuts its own strengths. The most glaring issue is the unnecessary extension of certain songs. One expects grandeur from Jungleland—its epic sweep demands it—but when more compact pieces such as The River or Tenth Avenue Freeze-Out are drawn out far beyond their natural lifespans, the result is dilution rather than intensification. The latter, in particular, buckles under the weight of self-congratulatory monologues and exhaustive band member introductions, transforming what should be a punchy crowd-pleaser into a plodding spectacle.

There’s also the matter of the band's vocal redistribution—a democratic impulse that, on paper, might seem charming. In execution, it proves far less compelling. During If I Should Fall Behind, a beautiful ballad by any measure, each member takes a line in what can only be described as a well-meaning misstep. What emerges is not a heartfelt moment of solidarity but a disjointed finale robbed of its original poignancy. The irony is thick: the original version, devoid of the E Street adornment, lands with greater emotional clarity.

Despite these misjudgments, Live in New York City still manages to affirm its worth. The inclusion of previously unreleased material—Land of Hope and Dreams, American Skin (41 Shots), Murder Incorporated—adds gravity and modern relevance. These are not perfunctory additions but powerful performances that anchor the concert in the contemporary moment. Older rarities such as Lost in the Flood and a brooding reinterpretation of Born in the U.S.A. demonstrate Springsteen's uncanny ability to reframe his past through the lens of present urgency.

The two tracks drawn from the then-recent Tracks collection may feel expendable, but such criticism feels more like nitpicking in a project defined by abundance. If anything, the wealth of material was both the album’s greatest asset and its Achilles’ heel. Still, the larger picture remains compelling: a historic band, once fractured, restored to full power—and with it, a reaffirmation that rock and roll, in the right hands, remains a spiritual force.

Go back to the main page
Go To Next Review