Sgt. Pepper Live (2009)
1. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
2. With a Little Help From My Friends
3. Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds
4. Getting Better
5. Fixing a Hole
6. She's Leaving Home
7. Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite
8. Within You Without You
9. When I'm Sixty-Four
10.Lovely Rita
11.Good Morning Good Morning
12.Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Ban (Reprise)
13.A Day in the Life
14.Medley Song
It was always going to be a gamble. The idea of Cheap Trick—a band rooted in the power
pop of the late ’70s—taking on Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, perhaps the most ambitious and sonically
intricate record in The Beatles’ catalog, feels equal parts audacious and ill-advised. But such is the nature of music
history: what seems foolhardy in concept sometimes makes sense in execution—though not, unfortunately, in this case.
The conceit, we’re told, was a Las Vegas residency. A Beatles tribute, but with pedigree. A rock band attempting the
impossible: to render live what the Fab Four themselves never did. Indeed, Sgt. Pepper was never toured—by design.
The Beatles had, by 1967, become a studio band. And Sgt. Pepper was their masterpiece of the laboratory,
awash with multitracked orchestration, sonic experimentation, and effects impossible to reproduce with a basic rock setup.
Enter Cheap Trick, who can echo the Beatles' sound with uncanny closeness in the right setting. But the question isn’t
fidelity—it’s intent. And here, the mismatch becomes apparent. Cheap Trick's strength has always been immediacy: guitars,
hooks, power choruses. Sgt. Pepper requires nuance, texture, even a certain detachment. The directness of Cheap Trick
jars with the kaleidoscopic haze of Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite or the Eastern mysticism of
Within You Without You—the latter a song so out of step with the band’s DNA that it defies logic why they attempted it at all.
To be fair, there are moments where it nearly lands. The opener, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, and the bright optimism of
Getting Better play to their strengths. But the album was never about just its rockers. Its genius lay in
the transitions, the textures, the interludes that made it more than the sum of its parts. The addition of outside vocalists—Joan Osborne
appears, puzzlingly, on Lovely Rita—only muddles the identity further. It ceases to be a band’s interpretation and becomes
a stage production in search of cohesion.
Perhaps the most telling criticism is logistical rather than musical. Why release this so soon after The Latest, an album
that had barely found its legs before this tribute came along to overshadow it? One can’t help but feel this was a project driven
more by commerce than by artistry. The band may have delivered what was asked, but at the cost of momentum and perhaps a little dignity.
In the end, Sgt. Pepper Live stands as an interesting curiosity. A band of great merit trying to pay homage to the greatest of all.
The idea was neat. The execution was not. Let's hope the check was worth it.
Go back to the main page
Go To the Next Review