Chestnut Street Incident (1976) 


 


  1. American Dream
  2. Pretty Woman
  3. Jailhouse Rock
  4. Dream Killing Town
  5. Supergirl
  6. Chestnut Street
  7. Good Girls
  8. Do You Believe in Magic
  9. Twentieth Century Fox
  10.Chestnut Street Revisited
  11.Sad Lady

 

Before he became a household name—or even John Mellencamp—he was “Johnny Cougar,” a moniker bestowed upon him without consent by a manager who believed the surname “Mellencamp” lacked commercial flair. It’s a detail Mellencamp has never concealed, and one he’s long expressed discomfort over. His debut album, The Chestnut Street Incident, released in 1976, is very much the product of that uneasy origin story.

Recorded under the guidance of industry handlers more interested in packaging than artistry, the album is a mishmash of ill-fitting cover songs and underdeveloped originals. At its best, it’s a curiosity. At its worst, it’s a misfire. It bears little resemblance to the rugged, authentic voice Mellencamp would later cultivate, and for good reason—it wasn’t quite his voice yet.

The tracklist includes perfunctory covers of standards like Jailhouse Rock and Twentieth Century Fox, neither of which offer any compelling reinterpretation. The original material fares no better. Songs like American Dream and Dream Killing Town aim for working-class narrative, but fall flat under thin arrangements and indistinct vocals. It's an album that never quite knows what it wants to be—part bar band, part industry product, part local demo polished a little too far.

Still, it’s difficult to cast too harsh a judgment viewing the background and the circumstances. Mellencamp was barely out of his teens when this was made, and like many young artists, he was doing what he was told, navigating a business that often prized image over substance. The Chestnut Street Incident wasn’t the debut of an artist with a clear vision; it was the debut of an artist still searching for one—awkward, uncertain, and entirely beholden to others’ expectations and manhandling by a greedy label.

In hindsight, the record serves as a case study than a launching pad. Mellencamp would go on to shed the Cougar branding, reclaim his name, and gradually shape one of the more enduring and credible careers in American rock. But none of that was evident here. The Chestnut Street Incident is a false start—embarrassing, yes, but also entirely forgivable.

Everyone has to begin somewhere. This just wasn’t the right place.

Go back to the main page
Go To Next Review