Rough Harvest (1999) 


 


  1. Love and Happiness
  2. In My Time of Dying
  3. Between a Laugh and a Tear
  4. Human Wheels
  5. Rain on the Scarecrow
  6. Farewell, Angelina
  7. Key West Intermezzo (I Saw You First)
  8. Jackie Brown
  9. When Jesus Left Birmingham
  10.The Full Catastrophe
  11.Minutes to Memories
  12.Under the Boardwalk
  13.Wild Night

 

Rough Harvest is one of those albums that probably wasn’t meant to make much noise. As a contractual obligation release, it arrived quietly in 1999 with a concept that’s straightforward: John Mellencamp revisiting selections from his back catalog in a stripped-down, acoustic, country-tinged style. And given how much of his earlier work had already leaned in that direction, the results here feel more like subtle reinterpretations than radical reimaginings.

That’s both the album’s strength and its limitation.

For longtime fans, there’s a certain charm in hearing familiar songs like Rain on the Scarecrow, Jackie Brown, or Minutes to Memories pared down to their core. Mellencamp always had a knack for rustic instrumentation—fiddles, mandolins, porch-swing rhythms—and Rough Harvest leans into that side of his musical identity. But since that aesthetic has long been a part of his DNA, none of these renditions feel particularly revelatory. They’re solid, well-played, and mostly pleasant—but rarely essential.

Whether or not these versions are “better” than the originals comes down to personal preference. In most cases, they don’t quite match the bite or energy of their earlier counterparts, but they do offer a more intimate reading—sometimes to good effect. These feel like songs being played in the quiet of late evening, rather than broadcast from a festival stage.

The covers, however, are another story. His version of Under the Boardwalk feels especially out of place—not just stylistically, but in tone. Mellencamp never sounded entirely at home with breezy nostalgia, and the song feels like filler here. In My Time of Dying, while more ambitious, doesn’t quite land either. And the live version of Wild Night, though spirited, disrupts the otherwise consistent mood of the record. It might’ve been better to leave the covers behind entirely and instead include a few more of his own lesser-known tracks, which might’ve benefited more from this kind of treatment.

All told, Rough Harvest really isn't that necessary of a listen. It plays more like a side project than a major statement, and while there’s nothing here to actively fault, there’s not much that demands repeated listens either. Still, for those who appreciate Mellencamp’s rootsier side, it’s a warm, low-key revisit of an already well-traveled road.

Not essential, but not without its modest rewards.

Go back to the main page
Go To Next Review