An American Treasure (2018)


 
Disc One 1. Surrender 2. Listen to Her Heart 3. Anything That's Rock 'N' Roll 4. When the Time Comes 5. You're Gonna Get It 6. Radio Promotion Spot 7. Rockin' Around (With You) 8. Fooled Again (I Don't Like It) 9. Breakdown 10.The Wild One, Forever 11.No Second Thoughts 12.Here Comes My Girl 13.What are You Doin' in My Life? 14.Louisiana Rain 15.Lost in Your Eyes Disc Two 1. Keep a Little Soul 2. Even the Losers 3. Keeping Me Alive 4. Don't Treat Me Like a Stranger 5. The Apartment Song 6. Concert Intro 7. Kings Road 8. Clear the Aisles 9. A Woman in Love (It's Not Me) 10.Straight into Darkness 11.You Can Still Change Your Mind 12.Rebels 13.Deliver Me 14.Alright for Now 15.The Damage You've Done 16.The Best of Everything 17.Walkin' from the Fire 18.King of the Hill Disc Three 1. I Won't Back Down 2. Gainesville 3. You and I Will Meet Again 4. Into the Great Wide Open 5. Two Gunslingers 6. Lonesome Dave 7. To Find a Friend 8. Crawling Back to You 9. Wake Up Time 10.Grew Up Fast 11.I Don't Belong 12.Accused of Love 13.Lonesome Sundown 14.Don't Fade on Me Disc Four 1. You and Me 2. Have Love, Will Travel 3. Money Becomes King 4. Bus to Tampa Bay 5. Saving Grace 6. Down South 7. Southern Accents 8. Insider 9. Two Men Taling 10.Fault Lines 11.Sins of My Youth 12.Good Enough 13.Something Good Coming 14.Save Your Water 15.Like a Diamond 16.Hungry No More

 

This is one of those releases that you have to wonder if it would have ever seen the light of day had Tom Petty not prematurely left us. My guess is serious fans (very serious) will look at this as a treasure trove, yet for most people, this will probably go over as being "noteworthy" but not necessarily "essential".

4 CDs chocked full of outtakes, unreleased tracks, live songs, and demos. Everything here is definitely "good" but unlike a Bob Dylan or a Bruce Springsteen, there's nothing really here that screams "must have". We must then remember that Petty released a 6 CD version back in the early 1990s, Playback, that had about half of that monstrous collection devoted to similar outputs. So in a sense, this seems like his closet is being cleaned out. I find it hard to conceive, though, that even the most devoted would listen to this often. It's nice to have, but definitely not a must.

Go back to the main page
Go to the Next Review